DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21271542

View latest PathMap Research

DISCLAIMER: This data is not peer reviewed and is NOT professional advice.
Original Text Evaluated

Why are frontotemporal dementia and c9orf72 ALS considered different diseases if they are both driven by the same abnormal expansion of a GGGGCC (G₄C₂) sequence in the first intron of the C9orf72 gene? Is it logical to think that CRISPR therapeutics for FTD potentially be used for ALS as well?

Plausibility Verdicts

Evaluation 1

FTD and ALS are distinct clinical syndromes sharing an identical genetic cause; therefore, CRISPR strategies targeting the C9orf72 expansion are fundamentally applicable to both.

Evaluation 2

FTD and C9orf72-ALS are clinical extremes of a single neurodegenerative spectrum driven by the same genetic expansion, making them prime candidates for unified gene-silencing therapeutics.

Dataset Summary

Novel & Overlooked Insights

  • ALS and FTD exist on a clinical and genetic continuum, meaning a patient may present with symptoms of both simultaneously (FTD-MND overlap).
  • The same C9orf72 expansion produces diverse phenotypes depending on modifiers such as age, sex, and polygenic background.
  • Biomarkers like neurofilament light chain (NfL) are being used to track neurodegeneration in both diseases, highlighting their biological similarities.
  • The role of microglial dysfunction and lysosomal repair deficiency in C9orf72 carriers is a convergent feature across the entire disease spectrum.
  • CRISPR-based excision is more efficient when targeting the intronic repeat region bi-allelically compared to allele-specific editing.
  • RNA structure, specifically G-quadruplexes and hairpins formed by G4C2 repeats, is a targetable druggable space common to both ALS and FTD.
  • The gut microbiome and energy metabolism impairments (such as reduced metabolic flexibility) are emerging as potential modifiers of disease progression in C9orf72-associated cases.
  • FTD and ALS are increasingly viewed as a unified clinical spectrum rather than strictly isolated disorders.
  • C9orf72 repeat expansions are associated with specific neuropathological changes, including the mislocalization of TDP-43 and DPR formation.
  • The C9orf72 repeat length can modulate phenotype, though it is not the sole determinant of whether a patient develops ALS, FTD, or both.
  • CRISPR-Cas9 and CRISPR-Cas13 (CasRx) systems are highly effective at reducing toxic RNA transcripts in both neuronal and glial models.
  • Genetic modifiers, such as *HTT* intermediate alleles, may accelerate age-of-onset in C9orf72 carriers, suggesting that personalized therapeutic strategies must account for individual genetic backgrounds.
  • There is a significant gap in our understanding of why identical repeat expansions lead to divergent clinical outcomes (ALS vs. FTD).
  • Glymphatic dysfunction and cortical free water have been identified as novel imaging biomarkers of disease progression in this genetic spectrum.
  • Therapeutic approaches targeting the Integrated Stress Response (ISR) or reducing DPR toxicity are currently being prioritized for clinical translation.
  • Neuroinflammation, driven by pathways like cGAS-STING and NLRP3, is a shared driver across the ALS/FTD spectrum, rather than merely a secondary effect.
  • Somatic mosaicism, including de novo somatic *C9orf72* repeat expansions, may explain why some patients develop widespread degeneration in a sporadic context.
  • The *C9orf72* expansion impacts microglial lysosomal repair through the RAB8A-ESCRT machinery, linking immunity to neurodegeneration.
  • "Cryptic exon" detection, specifically regarding *STMN2* and *UNC13A*, provides a proxy for TDP-43 mislocalization, which is a near-universal hallmark in this spectrum.
  • Fluid biomarkers such as plasma NEFL levels demonstrate a linear relationship with repeat burden, establishing a potential tool for monitoring treatment efficacy across the spectrum.
  • Innate immune activation, detectable via blood Interferon scores, is highest in *C9orf72* expansion carriers, suggesting distinct molecular subtypes.
  • The "dampening" of energy metabolism in cells harboring intermediate repeats (less than 30) suggests that repeat length, while traditionally dichotomized, exists on a functional continuum.

Extracted Discoveries

Suggested Experiments
  • Comparative CRISPR-Cas9 efficacy testing in patient-derived neuronal models of FTD versus ALS to identify phenotype-specific delivery optimization.
  • Investigate if correcting the C9orf72 repeat in asymptomatic carrier-derived neurons prevents FTD and ALS-like synaptic pruning vulnerability.
  • Evaluate if the same gRNA guides for repeat excision in FTD cohorts maintain off-target safety profiles in diverse ALS genetic backgrounds.
  • Assess the efficacy of AAV-delivered CasRx in non-human primate models of FTD to confirm safety and blood-brain barrier permeability.
  • Compare the impact of C9orf72-repeat excision on specific glial versus neuronal transcriptomes to ensure cell-type-specific therapeutic benefit.
  • Perform dual-readout longitudinal studies in C9orf72-ALS/FTD patient cohorts using both plasma NfL and imaging biomarkers to validate treatment responses.
  • Comparative analysis of CRISPR-mediated excision efficiency in patient-derived iPSC-MNs (ALS model) versus cortical neurons (FTD model).
  • Testing if the correction of C9ORF72 expansion in a combined neuro-glial organoid model rescues both motor and behavioral phenotypes simultaneously.
Suggested Studies
  • Longitudinal study comparing the impact of CRISPR repeat excision on fluid biomarkers (e.g., NfL) in both FTD and ALS-phenotype patients.
  • Cross-disorder meta-analysis of C9orf72-associated symptomatic patients to determine if specific genetic modifiers dictate FTD vs ALS expression.
  • A multi-center longitudinal clinical trial utilizing gene-targeted ASO therapies in both ALS and FTD cohorts to measure shared surrogate endpoints.
  • Integrative transcriptomic analysis of familial versus sporadic ALS patients who carry specific NEK1 or ATXN2 modifiers to refine patient stratification for gene therapy trials.
  • Large-scale proteomic study in CSF across both FTD and ALS phenotypes to define a 'universal' C9orf72-spectrum disease signature.
  • Longitudinal study comparing the trajectory of neurofilament light chain (NfL) in presymptomatic C9ORF72 carriers who later manifest as ALS vs FTD.
  • Multi-omics profiling of C9ORF72-associated cohorts to identify why some develop FTD-predominant vs ALS-predominant clinical syndromes.
Swansons Literature Based Discovery Candidates
  • Inhibition of the integrated stress response (ISR) via ATXN2 modulation may mitigate clinical symptoms in both ALS and FTD-MND cases.
  • Poly-GR toxicity in Drosophila models activates the integrated stress response (ID: 42087256).
  • Patients with behavioral variant FTD and motor neuron disease symptoms often demonstrate rapid cognitive and functional decline (ID: 42348055).
  • Ataxin-2 (ATXN2).
  • ATXN2 acts as an SG regulator that modulates the integrated stress response; reducing ATXN2 rescues motor deficits in poly(GR) models, suggesting a mechanism that could potentially stabilize FTD-MND phenotype progression.
  • Inhibition of the integrated stress response (ISR) in C9orf72-ALS may effectively rescue synaptic pruning defects commonly observed in comorbid major depressive disorder (MDD).
  • Poly(GR) dipeptide repeat proteins as activators of ISR in C9orf72-FTD/ALS (ID: 42087256)
  • Synaptic pruning vulnerability as a shared microglial substrate in MDD and ALS (ID: 42006515)
  • Microglial and neuronal stress granules/autophagy collapse
  • Since ISR activation drives stress granule formation, and stress granule dynamics are essential for proper synaptic pruning, moderating ISR in C9orf72-ALS could normalize the synaptic pruning processes disrupted in the comorbid MDD-ALS continuum.
  • The TYK2-dependent neuroinflammatory pathway identified in Alzheimer's may represent a master switch for the conversion of presymptomatic C9ORF72-ALS into symptomatic disease.
  • Alzheimer's Disease (TYK2-mediated inflammation in pTDP-43 brains) (Source 41832177)
  • C9ORF72-ALS progression markers (Immune reprogramming/progression) (Source 42135512)
  • TYK2 / Type-I Interferon signaling
  • Since TYK2 inhibition rescues cdsRNA-induced toxicity in both C9ORF72-ALS and TDP-43-AD models, and peripheral immune cells infiltrate the central nervous system in ALS progression, systemic TYK2 inhibition could be a viable target to prevent the onset of the ALS/FTD spectrum.
Contradictions Between Evidences
  • No overt contradictions identified regarding the shared genetic cause; however, studies note heterogeneity in phenotypic penetrance, suggesting environmental or polygenic modifiers remain poorly mapped.
  • Some studies highlight the clinical distinction of FTLD-TDP and LATE-NC (ID: 42388895) while others argue for a shared neurodegenerative spectrum (ID: 42412610, ID: 42359357).
  • Literature regarding the frequency of C9ORF72 variants in different global populations is highly variable (e.g., lower frequency in India compared to Europe/Hungary), which complicates universal disease stratification models.
Repurposed Solutions
  • CRISPR-Cas9 excision of C9orf72 repeats is being repurposed from initial in vitro FTD research into clinical-grade gene therapy development for ALS-FTD spectrum management.
  • Pizotifen malate (identified in C9orf72 zebrafish LOF models, ID: 41961863) shows potential for alleviating motor deficits and may be repurposed for human trials.
  • Dipyridamole (DPM) acts as a broad-spectrum neuroprotectant preventing mitochondrial fragmentation in both C9orf72 and Alzheimer's disease models (ID: 41646521).
  • The use of JAK inhibitors (baricitinib, ruxolitinib) and selective TYK2 inhibitors (deucravacitinib) originally for other inflammatory states shows potential for modulating the neuroinflammatory landscape of the ALS/FTD spectrum.
Support open science: Order your own dataset here.

Perfect for thesis ideas and a base concept for academic writings!

Each package comes with guaranteed unpublished discoveries!

Order now - $29.99

PathMap is funded by sales of datasets and coversheets to researchers of any kind who wish to discover the most viable routes and paths to accelerate cures. We do not make theoretical molecules, we expose the truth in current PubMed literature. Commission a trace today.

Investigator Profile

👨‍🔬
Joshua Dungan
PathMap Admin
PathMap PathMap Image